Padron Series Londres (Comparison Review)

Padron Series Londres - Natural and Maduro

Skip the fluff and jump straight to the review!

Cigar Stats
Brand Owner: Padron Cigars, Inc. – Miami, FL (website)
(distributor operates under the name Piloto Cigars, Inc.)
Factory: Tabacos Cubanica, S.A. – Esteli, Nicaragua
Factory: Tabacos Centroamericanos, S.A. – Danli, Honduras
Model/Vitola: Padron Series Londres (Natural and Maduro)
Size: 5.5 x 42 (corona)
Wrapper: Nicaragua
Filler & Binder: Nicaragua
Body: Medium to Full
Strength: Medium to Full
Average Retail: $2.65 USD
Cigar Insider/Aficionado Ratings: Consistently high 80s

Fourteen other vitola sizes are available in the traditional Padron Series along with one which was recently discontinued.

Frontmark

Length x Ring

Shape

2000

5.0 x 50

robusto

3000

5.5 x 52

robusto

4000

6.5 x 54

toro

5000

5.5 x 56

robusto

6000

5.5 x 52

torpedo

7000

6.25 x 60

toro

Ambassador

6.875 x 42

lonsdale

Chicos

5.5 x 36

discontinued

Churchill

6.875 x 46

churchill

Corticos

4.25 x 35

short panatela

Delicias

4.875 x 46

corona extra

Executive

7.5 x 50

double corona

Londres

5.5 x 42

corona

Magnum

9.0 x 50

giant

Palmas

6.25 x 42

long corona

Panetela

6.875 x 36

panetela

All sizes come in lacquered cedar boxes of 26, packaged with cellophane sleeves on individual cigars. Many vendors list a box size of 25. I am not entirely sure why that is. It may be that Padron changed the box count since the initial release. The Corticos are the exception packaged in boxes of 30 or tins of 6.

From the Padron website …..Jose Padron, Sr.

“We deliver only the finest, handmade, complex cigars with the flavor of the Cuban heritage out of which the Padron recipe was born. Our primary mission is the exceptional quality of our product, not the quantity produced. As a vertically integrated, family-owned company, we pay personal attention to every detail throughout all steps of our tobacco growing and cigar manufacturing process. Because we strive to give you, the smoker, the confidence that each cigar is the same ….. perfect.”

If you are interested in more KOTF info on the Padron Story, you can read it here.

The Keepers of the Flame Padron Series Roundup

Cigarfan & Lucky7

This comparison review is one in a series on the original Padron line of cigars. When we have completed reviews on the entire line, a vertical tasting for each wrapper will be published. Each review will be an amalgam opinion of cigarfan and lucky7 along with that of the guest reviewer(s). Our guest reviewer for this vitola is:

GeorgeE - The Stogie Guys

Padron Series Londres – Natural and Maduro

Padron Series Londres - Actual SizeThe Londres is the third corona in the classic Padron series, but unlike the others this one is a true corona. While the Palmas is long and slightly underweight and the Delicias is stubby and a little chubby, the Londres fits the corona standard exactly.

Cuba’s La Corona factory was the largest of its kind in the late nineteenth century, and it has been suggested that the name corona was first made popular by the La Corona Coronas made there. As time wore on, the term corona became central to the industry, spawning gran coronas, petit coronas, double coronas, etc., and eventually became the standard against which other vitolas were compared.

The appellation “Londres” can only mean that the corona was as popular in London as it was everywhere else. Maybe this was the perfect size to smoke in the drizzle under the gas lamps of old London, but is it the perfect size in the Padron series for our smokers today?

As our panel found out, maybe not.

Natural

The Natural wrapper imparts a familiar rustic appearance to this cigar: it’s ruddy, bumpy and wrinkled with a slightly grainy texture. George noted an uneven cap that threatened to unravel the cigar upon cutting (he was surprised when it didn’t) and a wrapper “marred by numerous small tears.”

Londres Natural with a vein spike - ouch!

Lucky7 smoked a sample with a special new design feature: a vein spiking through the wrapper right on the edge of the head. Maybe that allows the smoker to gain a tighter purchase on the cigar in a strong wind.

On the bright side, the roll is firm and the draw is free. It produces a nice volume of smoke with ease and exhibits no burn problems. The prelight scent and cold flavors are typical of the line: grassy tobacco with a hint of the pasture.

The Natural Londres fires up quickly and offers a grumpy greeting: lucky7 called the first inch “raspy”, while cigarfan noted a mild bite. The aroma is sweet and somewhat nutty; lucky7 compared it to “strong sweet tea with a twang.” After the peppery and slightly harsh prelude, there are notes of cocoa, coffee, and leather. There is a touch of sweetness on the palate.

The mid-section marks a turning point. The flavors begin to intensify and turn from slightly sweet to slightly bitter. The nose twang starts to wane. It is solidly medium-bodied with a moderately long finish and slightly ashy flavor. It is imperative to smoke this cigar slowly or it will burn hot and get mean.

The final stage of this cigar is bitter and strong and was not met with applause by any of us, least of all George. Cigarfan and lucky7 found some merit in the first two-thirds of the Londres, even if they were not terribly impressed by cigar overall, but George’s opinion speaks for itself:

From the start, the Londres natural was not enjoyable. It was hot, no matter how much time I allowed between puffs. I’m a fairly slow smoker generally and with both of these I made an extra effort to slow down even more. It seemed to make little difference, with the natural burning particularly rapidly.

And while it produced copious amounts of smoke, the taste was acrid and the finish long and sharp… Unlike the maduro, the natural got harsher as I continued to smoke. I continued smoking, occasionally tapping off the gray black ash, and Londres Natural with quarter for comparisonhoped for some positive developments. But at about the two-inch mark I gave up, my taste buds overwhelmed by the bitter taste and disappointment.

Maduro

The maduro Londres rated a little bit above average in appearance for this line. While still roughshod in general, the caps were applied well (with one exception), the roll was firm and without soft spots, and there were no protruding veins. As with the other sizes, the maduro Londres is only a few shades darker than the natural.

The prelight characteristics are similar to the natural version: straightforward tobacco; additionally, George reported a minty prelight scent in both natural and maduro wrappers.

The flavors and smoking characteristics of the maduro were very similar to the natural: a spicy and somewhat harsh introduction followed by a medium-bodied smoke with a foundation of leather and toasted wood. Substitute a slightly heavier dose of chocolate for the natural’s cocoa and it could be the same cigar.

Lucky7's Londres Maduro - 1st Ash

Once again, the Londres tends to get bitter and smoke hot starting in the second third. The aroma is pleasant and the flavor begins to intensify, though perhaps in a way that isn’t entirely laudable.

The last third continues down this precarious road to an inhospitable conclusion: hot and finally acrid. George sums it up:

There was a little spice in the beginning that dropped off after about a half-inch as the bitterness increased. Although I didn’t find the finish particularly dry, I did notice that when I drank a lot of water after about the first third the bitterness seemed to subside somewhat. At that point, the cigar devolved into just a sort of bland, boring smoke with some unpleasant tones.

Of the two, I preferred the maduro Londres, if for no other reason than the bitterness and harsh finish subsided before the end of the cigar.

Conclusion

There is a moment for the Londres after the initial harshness subsides and the subsequent bitterness begins when this is a flavorful corona with all of the traits we expect in a Padron cigar: a rich woody flavor with hints of leather and cocoa or chocolate that goes exactly where you’d expect a Padron to go. The problem with the Londres is that this flavor is only momentary.

Like the Delicias, this cigar can be enjoyed up to a point. As lucky7 puts it,

This is a very straight forward little corona which has some nice flavors in the first half, then turns mediocre over the second. There is some unpleasant bitterness associated with the final third which will definitely turn some folks off. Even with the low price point, I do not consider the Londres the best value.

George concludes with suspicions about the quality standards employed in rolling this cigar:

Though there were many similarities in the natural and maduro, both were sharp and harsh, presenting almost no complexity. Even the taste of the tobacco was unpleasant. It’s hard not to assume Padron rolls this line from leaves that didn’t measure up to the quality standards for any of its other cigars.

As a Padron fan, I find it hard to be so negative about any of their cigars. but having had, probably, six or eight Londres over the past few years, these two reinforced the reactions I’d had before.

We all agreed on one point: while this is an inexpensive cigar, there are better options to choose from in this line.

Thanks to GeorgeE for his candid contribution. To be cruel is to be kind, in this case to our readers and to the cigar consumer at large. Be sure to check in to the Stogie Guys for daily cigar news and George’s always frank and incisive reviews.

… cigarfan & lucky7

Padron Series 3000 (Comparison Review)

Padron Series 3000 - Natural and Maduro

Skip the fluff and jump straight to the review!

Cigar Stats
Brand Owner: Padron Cigars, Inc. – Miami, FL (website)
(distributor operates under the name Piloto Cigars, Inc.)
Factory: Tabacos Cubanica, S.A. – Esteli, Nicaragua
Factory: Tabacos Centroamericanos, S.A. – Danli, Honduras
Model/Vitola: Padron Series 3000 (Natural and Maduro)
Size: 5.5 x 52 (robusto)
Wrapper: Nicaragua
Filler & Binder: Nicaragua
Body: Medium to Full
Strength: Medium to Full
Average Retail: $5.38 USD
Cigar Insider/Aficionado Ratings: Consistently high 80s to low 90s

Fourteen other vitola sizes are available in the traditional Padron Series along with one which was recently discontinued.

Frontmark

Length x Ring

Shape

2000

5.0 x 50

robusto

3000

5.5 x 52

robusto

4000

6.5 x 54

toro

5000

5.5 x 56

robusto

6000

5.5 x 52

torpedo

7000

6.25 x 60

toro

Ambassador

6.875 x 42

lonsdale

Chicos

5.5 x 36

discontinued

Churchill

6.875 x 46

churchill

Corticos

4.25 x 35

short panatela

Delicias

4.875 x 46

corona extra

Executive

7.5 x 50

double corona

Londres

5.5 x 42

corona

Magnum

9.0 x 50

giant

Palmas

6.25 x 42

long corona

Panetela

6.875 x 36

panetela

All sizes come in lacquered cedar boxes of 26, packaged with cellophane sleeves on individual cigars. Many vendors list a box size of 25. I am not entirely sure why that is. It may be that Padron changed the box count since the initial release. The Corticos are the exception packaged in boxes of 30 or tins of 6.

From the Padron website …..Jose Padron, Sr.

“We deliver only the finest, handmade, complex cigars with the flavor of the Cuban heritage out of which the Padron recipe was born. Our primary mission is the exceptional quality of our product, not the quantity produced. As a vertically integrated, family-owned company, we pay personal attention to every detail throughout all steps of our tobacco growing and cigar manufacturing process. Because we strive to give you, the smoker, the confidence that each cigar is the same ….. perfect.”

If you are interested in more KOTF info on the Padron Story, you can read it here.

The Keepers of the Flame Padron Series Roundup

Cigarfan & Lucky7

This comparison review is one in a series on the original Padron line of cigars. When we have completed reviews on the entire line, a vertical tasting for each wrapper will be published. Each review will be an amalgam opinion of cigarfan and lucky7 along with that of the guest reviewer(s). Our guest reviewers for this vitola are:

Matt - Matt's Cigar Journal

Jesse - Cigar Jack

Padron Series 3000 – Natural and Maduro

Matt's Review Pair - Actual SizePadron’s “Thousands” series of cigars are all robusto or robusto-plus sized cigars. The 3000 is a slightly larger than average robusto; at 5 1/2 x 52 it has just a little more girth and half an inch in length on the standard 5 x 50 robusto.

Based on our reviewers’ impressions, it’s safe to say that the 3000 does not depart from the rusticity that characterizes the rest of the Padron Series we’ve examined so far. If there’s one consistent element here, it’s a rough and ready blue-collar exterior.

Natural

The most impressive aesthetic feature of the 3000 Natural is its well formed and flattened head. Like the triple-cap, the flat head has traditionally been a hallmark of Cuban craftsmanship and quite a few non-Cuban manufacturers have appropriated the style. Unfortunately for the 3000 natural, this otherwise attractive element is defeated by a haphazard application of the cap. The caps seemed to be uniformly sloppy; in one case the cap was loose and made cutting the cigar a challenge — just tear off the cap flapping loose in the breeze, or cut further down?

3000 Natural - Wrinkled HeadHurdling over these flaws, what we have is typical of the Padron Series Natural: a rough, somewhat veiny wrapper with a consistently textured milk chocolate color, a passable roll with a slight box press, and a good draw. The prelight scent is that familiar horsey Old McDonald smell — Jesse describes it as leather, while Matt notes hay and earth. Sounds like the barnyard all right.

The natural lights up easily and introduces itself with a smattering of pepper that quickly gives way to leather. All four reviewers noted leather as a main ingredient here, three of us found a woody element as well, and Jesse tasted some coffee. The finish is very short and a tad salty.

The middle section continues in the same vein but gets creamier and adds a small shot of sweetness. Cigarfan picked up a little cocoa; Jesse stayed with his coffee; Matt noted some subtle spiciness on top of the base of wood and leather, and Lucky7 contented himself with blowing rings with the thick creamy smoke.

Lucky7's 3000 Natural - 1st Ash

The body of the cigar grows to a solid medium-plus in the last section. (Matt thought it was lighter than this, but in reading his reviews you’ll find that he is partial to some thundering smokes.) As always, gauging the body and strength of a cigar is very subjective. What we all agreed on was this: leather. Leather with nuts, leather with coffee, and leather with wood. For dessert, the 3000 natural serves up a few crusts of toasty bread and a touch of caramel.

Matt sums it up:

Even though it has an ugly appearance it is a very well constructed cigar. The ash held firm and was well formed with a good burn and excellent draw. The flavors, although a little one dimensional, are very good, making for a good easy going and enjoyable smoke. I’d rate this a good everyday kind of smoke.

Jesse's Review Pair (the Maduro's on top)

 

Maduro

Padron’s natural cigars are much darker than the average “natural” due to the sungrown Habano leaf that is used. The processing of maduro leaf provides additional fermentation, but in this case it results in a wrapper that is only slightly darker than the natural. This is evident across many of the different vitolas, and this is the case with the 3000. Viewed separately it is quite difficult to differentiate between the natural and the maduro 3000s. (Which is why it’s always a good idea to label these cigars if you are placing them in the same humidor compartments.)

3000 Maduro - Wrinkled HeadIn other ways the maduro is quite similar to the natural, including the rough wrapper and sloppy cap. As Matt says, it’s “just as ugly as the natural.” There are lumps and veins and wrinkles and the occasional soft spot — once again, this cigar will not elicit sighs of admiration based on its presentation.

George E. from the Stogie Guys weighed in on the 3000 as well, noting a prelight minty scent that follows through to the taste on a cold draw. Cigarfan was a little surprised to find the faint scent of ammonia on one sample, but a simple sweet tobacco scent on the rest.

All of our reviewers found sweet bean flavors in the first third, though some identified this as coffee and others as cocoa. Lucky7 found a hint of cinnamon and vanilla, while cigarfan caught just a glimpse of that coconut/hazelnut he’s been finding in the maduros in this series. The burning qualities were reported by everyone to be very good, with an even burn line and a solid, though somewhat flaky ash.

3000 Maduro with quarter for comparisonThe flavors turn to wood in the middle section, along with the sweet char typical of maduro wrapper leaf. At this point the body builds up to a solid medium and the cigar gathers a little strength. The finish is short but gets a little sharp if you’re puffing too vigorously. Jesse wondered at this point if his stick “might be a bit off or my taste is off. I remember past ones to be sweeter — more chocolate.” In agreement with this, George noted “burnt coffee.” There are definitely bittersweet overtones at this point.

The flavors grow a little darker in the last third. Some peppery flavors come into play and the finish lengthens. The aroma is still quite nice at this point, smoldering a sweet hickory charcoal scent. The last inch and half gets hot and produces an unpleasant bite, signaling the end stage of this cigar.

Conclusion

Jesse noticed some inconsistency with the maduro version of this cigar, so cigarfan felt compelled to grab a couple at his local shop for comparison purposes. There does seem to be some inconsistency here — it isn’t severe, but as Jesse points out in his review of the Padron 6000 at Cigar Jack there may be some quality control issues to look out for. On the other hand, this is not a super-premium smoke — for most people cigars in this series are considered quality “everyday” cigars. But the caveat is out there.

These are straightforward cigars that don’t exhibit a lot of complexity or remarkable development. They’re medium bodied smokes that are characteristic of the Padron Series — a lot of bean flavors, with an added bittersweet char in the maduro.

Matt’s summary says it all:

These cigars are a prime illustration of how a wrapper can affect the overall experience of a blend. The maduro is very different from the natural: it is a bit more complex. The natural is a good cigar, but I feel the maduro is the superior of the two. Lots of flavor, but still a very accessible easy going smoke. It is a good cigar for beginners and still has plenty to offer the more experienced.

Thanks to Matt, Jesse and GeorgeE for their comments. Be sure to check out Matt’s Cigar Journal, especially if you’re a fan of Don Pepin Garcia and heavier bodied fare, and Cigar Jack, who seems to be on top of the cigar news faster than the AP wire. Thanks to all for taking part in this round of the Padron Roundup!

… cigarfan & lucky7

Padron Series Delicias (Comparison Review)

Padron Series Delicias - Natural & Maduro

Skip the fluff and jump straight to the review!

Cigar Stats
Brand Owner: Padron Cigars, Inc. – Miami, FL (website)
(distributor operates under the name Piloto Cigars, Inc.)
Factory: Tabacos Cubanica, S.A. – Esteli, Nicaragua
Factory: Tabacos Centroamericanos, S.A. – Danli, Honduras
Model/Vitola: Padron Series Delicias (Natural and Maduro)
Size: 4.875 x 46 (corona extra)
Wrapper: Nicaragua
Filler & Binder: Nicaragua
Body: Medium to Full
Strength: Medium to Full
Average Retail: $3.46 USD
Cigar Insider/Aficionado Ratings: Consistently high 80s

Fourteen other vitola sizes are available in the traditional Padron Series along with one which was recently discontinued.

Frontmark

Length x Ring

Shape

2000

5.0 x 50

robusto

3000

5.5 x 52

robusto

4000

6.5 x 54

toro

5000

5.5 x 56

robusto

6000

5.5 x 52

torpedo

7000

6.25 x 60

toro

Ambassador

6.875 x 42

lonsdale

Chicos

5.5 x 36

discontinued

Churchill

6.875 x 46

churchill

Corticos

4.25 x 35

short panatela

Delicias

4.875 x 46

corona extra

Executive

7.5 x 50

double corona

Londres

5.5 x 42

corona

Magnum

9.0 x 50

giant

Palmas

6.25 x 42

long corona

Panetela

6.875 x 36

panetela

All sizes come in lacquered cedar boxes of 26, packaged with cellophane sleeves on individual cigars. Many vendors list a box size of 25. I am not entirely sure why that is. It may be that Padron changed the box count since the initial release. The Corticos are the exception packaged in boxes of 30 or tins of 6.

From the Padron website …..Jose Padron, Sr.

“We deliver only the finest, handmade, complex cigars with the flavor of the Cuban heritage out of which the Padron recipe was born. Our primary mission is the exceptional quality of our product, not the quantity produced. As a vertically integrated, family-owned company, we pay personal attention to every detail throughout all steps of our tobacco growing and cigar manufacturing process. Because we strive to give you, the smoker, the confidence that each cigar is the same ….. perfect.”

If you are interested in more KOTF info on the Padron Story, you can read it here.

The Keepers of the Flame Padron Series Roundup

Cigarfan & Lucky7

This comparison review is one in a series on the original Padron line of cigars. When we have completed reviews on the entire line, a vertical tasting for each wrapper will be published. Each review will be an amalgam opinion of cigarfan and lucky7 along with that of the guest reviewer(s). Our guest reviewer for this vitola is:

JonN - The Stogie Guys

Padron Series Delicias – Natural and Maduro

“Delicias” is a commercial vitola with no standard dimensions. The best known Delicias is the one made in Cuba for Fonseca — ironically, the factory vitola for Fonseca’s Delicias is called “Standard.” That cigar measures 4 15/16 inches by a 40 ring gauge. Other Delicias are much larger, such as Don Pepin’s 7 x 50 churchill, or smaller, like the 30 gauge mini Cubita Delicias. All of which have no relation to Padron’s fat corona in our sights today.

Both the natural and maduro versions of Padron’s Delicias look like they’ve just come in from a hard day on the range, an attribute common to the classic Padron Series. And they smoke a lot like they look — they dispense with the formalities and get down to business right away.

Natural

Delicias Natural FootThe wrapper on this cigar is remarkably swarthy for a “natural.” The wrapper’s edges look more ripened than the rest of the leaf, giving it a foxed appearance. The head is nicely formed and finished with a flat cap. The roll of the cigar varied from firm to very spongy, but the draw was consistently free. Jon described it as ” bumpy, lumpy, a bit lopsided, and full of tooth,” an observation we all agreed with. Clearly this stick is not a natural beauty, but as Jon went on to say,

…the rusticity of the Delicias is endearing. When I look at this cigar, warts and all, I imagine what cigars must have looked like hundreds of years ago: rough, bumpy, and raw. I kind of dig it.

Delicias Natural AshThe Delicias opens up with the eye-opening blast of pepper well known by fans of Nicaraguan tobacco. It quickly settles down to a woody base with a sweet leathery aroma. It burns a bit recklessly, but doesn’t require correction, meanwhile producing a light gray ash with black accents.

Bean flavors take the spotlight in the second third, though Jon noticed these in the first third as well. Up front there are cocoa, coffee and a gentler spiciness as the cigar seems to be taking a break at this point. Toasted wood lingers in the background, and the aroma remains basically leathery. Cigarfan noted some hickory aspects to the aroma and found the aftertaste quite tangy.

Lucky7's Delicias Natural NubThe last section is marked by increasing intensity. The flavor becomes earthier, and the pepper returns with a vengeance. Lucky7 described this section as “very strong tobacco” while cigarfan experienced a strong peppery flavor bordering on harsh and noted a hot burn and a bitter aftertaste.

Jon concluded with an apt metaphor:

The Delicias picks up where it left off in the home stretch: regaining its initial strength, and building up a steady backbone of pepper. If this cigar were a symphony, the first movement would be blustery and full of vigor; the second movement would be light and airy; the third would be a thundering crescendo.

Maduro

Delicias Maduro with quarter for comparisonThe maduro Delicias is just a couple shades darker than the natural version, but it’s just as rough hewn in appearance. The roll is firm with a slight square press. Once again, we can’t resist Jon’s description of this bad boy:

Like its natural cousin, the Delicias maduro is quite rustic in appearance. It’s toothy, its seams are defiantly visible, and its gnarled, slightly box-pressed shape will not win any beauty contests. Nevertheless, there is an enjoyable machismo on display here. This little cigar has a bit of a Napoleon complex: it’s short, but it’s rugged and ready to rumble. If this cigar has a personality, it’s that of a turn-of-the-century, bareknuckle prizefighter.

After an initially raspy burst of spice this cigar mellows into a surprisingly complex brew of earthy tobacco, coffee and sweet maduro flavors, though lucky7 thought the sweetness slightly reduced in comparison with the others we’ve reviewed for the Roundup so far. Cigarfan noticed a recurring flavor that is becoming for him the signature of Padron maduros: a sweet coconut or hazelnut flavor, but like lucky7 he found it to be a little less pronounced here. Jon described this flavor as “hazelnut, honey, and occasional notes of clove. Additionally, there’s a delightful honey-graham aroma to the smoke that is intoxicating.”

Lucky7's Delicias 1st Ash (Natural on top)

In the second stage the smoke becomes creamy smooth and the flavors subside a bit. There’s a little bit of pepper, but it’s not as powerful as the natural and the finish is much shorter. It is similarly medium-bodied, and all other construction qualities are Gentleman Jim Corbetton par with the natural — not perfect in terms of burn, but good enough for Gentleman Jim Corbett.

The last third revisits some of the earlier peppery notes from the first section and the aroma picks up more char. Jon experienced more complexity at this point than the other reviewers did, marking coffee and cedar, while cigarfan and lucky7 found mostly strong and straightforward tobacco flavors. Once again the last third spirals down into bitterness, but less dramatically than the natural.

Conclusion

The Padron Delicias is not the trifle that its name would suggest — it’s a fairly potent forthright cigar that provides an hour of serious smoking. The maduro and the natural versions of this cigar have their own distinct personalities, but they share a feisty disposition. That said, our reviewers agreed that the maduro took an edge over the natural in terms of complexity, smoothness, and overall performance. Lucky7 sums it up well when he says that he “would recommend this vitola to experienced smokers who can handle full power at the nub or the medium-bodied smoker who wants to quit two-thirds of the way through.” The Delicias is no bon bon.

Thanks to JonN for contributing his insightful comments and some great prose to this comparison review. Be sure to check out his articles at StogieGuys.com — we think they’re some of the best written pieces in the business.

… cigarfan & lucky7

Padron Series Magnum (Comparison Review)

Padron Series Magnum - Natural & Maduro

Skip the fluff and jump straight to the review!

Cigar Stats
Brand Owner: Padron Cigars, Inc. – Miami, FL (website)
(distributor operates under the name Piloto Cigars, Inc.)
Factory: Tabacos Cubanica, S.A. – Esteli, Nicaragua
Factory: Tabacos Centroamericanos, S.A. – Danli, Honduras
Model/Vitola: Padron Series Magnum (Natural and Maduro)
Size: 9.0 x 50 (toro)
Wrapper: Nicaragua
Filler & Binder: Nicaragua
Body: Medium to Full
Strength: Medium to Full
Average Retail: $9.04 USD
Cigar Insider/Aficionado Ratings: Consistently low to mid 90s

Fourteen other vitola sizes are available in the traditional Padron Series along with one which was recently discontinued.

Frontmark

Length x Ring

Shape

2000

5.0 x 50

robusto

3000

5.5 x 52

robusto

4000

6.5 x 54

toro

5000

5.5 x 56

robusto

6000

5.5 x 52

torpedo

7000

6.25 x 60

toro

Ambassador

6.875 x 42

lonsdale

Chicos

5.5 x 36

discontinued

Churchill

6.875 x 46

churchill

Corticos

4.25 x 35

short panatela

Delicias

4.875 x 46

corona extra

Executive

7.5 x 50

double corona

Londres

5.5 x 42

corona

Magnum

9.0 x 50

giant

Palmas

6.25 x 42

long corona

Panetela

6.875 x 36

panetela

All sizes come in lacquered cedar boxes of 26, packaged with cellophane sleeves on individual cigars. Many vendors list a box size of 25. I am not entirely sure why that is. It may be that Padron changed the box count since the initial release. The Corticos are the exception packaged in boxes of 30 or tins of 6.

From the Padron website …..Jose Padron, Sr.

“We deliver only the finest, handmade, complex cigars with the flavor of the Cuban heritage out of which the Padron recipe was born. Our primary mission is the exceptional quality of our product, not the quantity produced. As a vertically integrated, family-owned company, we pay personal attention to every detail throughout all steps of our tobacco growing and cigar manufacturing process. Because we strive to give you, the smoker, the confidence that each cigar is the same ….. perfect.”

If you are interested in more KOTF info on the Padron Story, you can read it here.

The Keepers of the Flame Padron Series Roundup

Cigarfan & Lucky7

This comparison review is one in a series on the original Padron line of cigars. When we have completed reviews on the entire line, a vertical tasting for each wrapper will be published. Each review will be an amalgam opinion of cigarfan and lucky7 along with that of the guest reviewer(s). Our guest reviewer for this vitola is:

Walt - Stogie Review

Padron Series Magnum – Natural and Maduro

Padron Series Magnum - One Mamoth CigarAlso known as a gran corona, the “A” size has Cuban roots in cigars such as the Sancho Panza Sancho and most famously, the Montecristo A. Large format cigars like the double corona and the “A” require very large wrapper leaves of superior quality, a commodity which is in high demand depending on the success of the season’s harvest and the manufacturer’s back stock.

The Padron Magnum is technically not an “A” size cigar, but at 9 inches long by a 50 ring gauge, it certainly falls into the same family of “giant” cigars. If not the largest, it is at least the longest cigar made by the Padron family.

As Walt says, this cigar is “comically large” and all of our reviewers found it rather unwieldy. It’s not comfortable to hold in the mouth (though doing so allows one the opportunity to imitate Sid Caesar) and Lucky7 found that he had to search for a fulcrum point to keep it balanced in the hand.

Walt noted that the sheer size of the Magnum requires four wraps of the leaf to encompass the bunch, rather than the typical three. The size of the leaf required may also be responsible for its smooth and consistent texture — the natural Magnum in particular is one of the more attractive cigars in the classic Padron Series.

Natural

The Magnum’s natural claro wrapper is a pleasant milk chocolate tone with contrasting darker splotches. The roll is fairly soft and has a slight square press. The prelight scent is of compost, the proverbial “barnyard,” and the draw is free. Walt noted a taste of mild toffee on the cold draw.

We were all a little concerned about the amount of time required to smoke this monster. Walt is notorious for his slow methodical enjoyment of even normal sized cigars, so he Magnum Natural with Quarter for comparisonreserved four hours and still felt a bit rushed. His smoking time came in just over three hours; we all agreed that this cigar smokes more quickly than we expected. Lucky7’s smoking time came in at two hours; cigarfan’s about two and a half.

The Magnum burns well, though it does waver from time to time. The extensive barrel results in a cool smoke, and it forms a conical crown. Walt noticed a blistering effect at the burn line for the first half of the cigar.

A cigar of this size could easily be divided into quarters rather than thirds for flavor assessment purposes, but the flavor transitions it goes through are not dramatic enough to warrant that. The first third is marked by a straightforward flavor of leather and earth with a bright acidic tang. It’s a little dry, and Walt found some “muted coffee with a mild fruit like sweetness.” It appears to be about medium in both body and strength.

Our reviewers glowingly endorsed the second third as “lackluster” and “more of the same.” A little more leather, some earthy cocoa flavors, and the tang seems to fade a little. Walt bided his time by passing the smoke through his sinuses and found some pepper and spice that aren’t apparent on the palate.

Into the last section the smoke gets creamier in body and the aroma picks up a caramel-nutty flavor. The body moves toward full and the smoke gets a little more aggressive. Walt picked up leather, toast, wood and dry earth as main components, with a “mild fruit like sweetness, pepper and spice” in the background. By the end, the tang has been replaced by pepper, and the flavors wash out into a dirty, somewhat tarry conclusion. Nubbing this giant rewards the brave smoker with a harsh and bitter tasting dose of pepper.

Maduro

The maduro wrapper is similar to the natural in consistency but is of course darker, oilier, and it has an attractively grainy texture. The caps are well formed, but the heads of these cigars seem a little fragile. In one a crack near the head caused the wrapper to tear off with the cap when it was removed, exposing the binder leaf beneath. Walt’s sample had a small hole that he noticed after clipping the cap.

But the roll is good — it’s a little firmer than the natural, similarly square pressed, and the resulting draw is free with just the right amount of resistance. The wrapper has a mild prelight scent and minimal taste on a cold draw.

Walt's Magnum Maduro

Walt found the maduro Magnum to be a slow starter — after 20 minutes he was still looking for the flavors he normally enjoys from Padron maduros. He found some dull flavors of earth with mild coffee overtones, while Lucky7 noted an “aroma of strong sweet tea with a small twang.” In addition to the coffee that Walt noticed, cigarfan detected a touch of leather. For the first third the flavor is fairly constant and there isn’t much development.

This maduro finally started to open up for Walt about half-way through the smoke, 90 minutes after ignition. The body and strength have stepped it up a notch to a medium level and the smoke has become rich and creamy. The flavors here are of earth and coffee, with a dash of pepper. There are notes of cocoa and sweet char on the nose.

Lucky7's Magnum Maduro - 1st Ash

The last third features some bittersweet chocolate and brings back the leather from the first section. Walt found an interesting “off and on dark fruity flavor, sort of wine like,” and at long last the maduro flavors he was expecting from the start stand up and add character to the smoke. The finish lengthens and exits with a peppery aftertaste.

Conclusion

Even though this cigar clocked in at less than the three or four hours we were expecting, it still turned into an endurance contest. Maybe there is a hidden art to smoking the giant cigar, but we were all less than completely impressed with the Magnum. As Walt says, there’s just “too much waiting for the flavors to come into their own.” It’s like sitting through two hours of average opening acts to hear your favorite band play. The openers may put on a decent show, but it’s not what you paid to hear.

On the other hand, this is a decent cigar for a great price. Very large cigars are not easy to make and require massive leaves that are often difficult to acquire, one reason why the Cuban Montecristo A is one of the world’s most expensive regular production cigars. The Padron Magnum might not be the tastiest or most exciting cigar in the Padron Series, but in light of its basic materials and construction it is certainly a good value.

Our thanks to Walt for running the gauntlet with us! It’s been a pleasure, and as always we look forward to his reviews on Stogiereview.com.

… cigarfan & lucky7

Padron Series Palmas (Comparison Review)

Padron Palmas - Natural & Maduro

Skip the fluff and jump straight to the review!

Cigar Stats
Brand Owner: Padron Cigars, Inc. – Miami, FL (website)
(distributor operates under the name Piloto Cigars, Inc.)
Factory: Tabacos Cubanica, S.A. – Esteli, Nicaragua
Factory: Tabacos Centroamericanos, S.A. – Danli, Honduras
Model/Vitola: Padron Series Palmas (Natural and Maduro)
Size: 6.25 x 42 (long corona)
Wrapper: Nicaragua
Filler & Binder: Nicaragua
Body: Medium to Full
Strength: Medium to Full
Average Retail: $3.50 USD
Cigar Insider/Aficionado Ratings: Consistently high 80s to low 90s

Fourteen other vitola sizes are available in the traditional Padron Series along with one which was recently discontinued.

Frontmark

Length x Ring

Shape

2000

5.0 x 50

robusto

3000

5.5 x 52

robusto

4000

6.5 x 54

toro

5000

5.5 x 56

robusto

6000

5.5 x 52

torpedo

7000

6.25 x 60

toro

Ambassador

6.875 x 42

lonsdale

Chicos

5.5 x 36

discontinued

Churchill

6.875 x 46

churchill

Corticos

4.25 x 35

short panatela

Delicias

4.875 x 46

corona extra

Executive

7.5 x 50

double corona

Londres

5.5 x 42

corona

Magnum

9.0 x 50

giant

Palmas

6.25 x 42

long corona

Panetela

6.875 x 36

panetela

All sizes come in lacquered cedar boxes of 26, packaged with cellophane sleeves on individual cigars. Many vendors list a box size of 25. I am not entirely sure why that is. It may be that Padron changed the box count since the initial release. The Corticos are the exception packaged in boxes of 30 or tins of 6.

From the Padron website …..Jose Padron, Sr.

“We deliver only the finest, handmade, complex cigars with the flavor of the Cuban heritage out of which the Padron recipe was born. Our primary mission is the exceptional quality of our product, not the quantity produced. As a vertically integrated, family-owned company, we pay personal attention to every detail throughout all steps of our tobacco growing and cigar manufacturing process. Because we strive to give you, the smoker, the confidence that each cigar is the same ….. perfect.”

If you are interested in more KOTF info on the Padron Story, you can read it here.

The Keepers of the Flame Padron Series Roundup

Cigarfan & Lucky7

This comparison review is one in a series on the original Padron line of cigars. When we have completed reviews on the entire line, a vertical tasting for each wrapper will be published. Each review will be an amalgam opinion of cigarfan and lucky7 along with that of the guest reviewer(s). Our guest reviewer for this vitola is:

Lisa - Her Humidor

Padron Series Palmas – Natural and Maduro

Padron Palmas - Actual SizeThose of us who have been around for a while know that the names manufacturers choose for their cigars do not always follow standard nomenclature. We all remember our first trips into the humidor, gazing starry-eyed at the assortment of cigars and wondering what all the different terms mean. Eventually our confusion is compounded when we find out that what one cigar maker calls a “toro” another one calls a “corona gorda” and another one calls a “robusto extra,” and so forth.

In the same spirit, the term “Palmas” is a little misleading here. The Padron Palmas is a little too large to be a traditional palmas, which is a slim panatela with a 33 ring gauge. What we have here is something closer to a lonsdale, or a long corona.

Natural

If you were to remove the band from this cigar and offer it to an experienced cigar smoker, you might get a piercing glare, or at least a hearty guffaw for your trouble. This is not a pretty stick. Our reviewers described it as bumpy, misshapen, and most forgivingly, rustic. One sample was cracked at the head and required a bit of magic mending tape to render it smokable. (Yet another example of the fearless ingenuity of the dedicated cigar smoker.)

Palmas Natural with QuarterIn addition to its slovenly appearance, the Palmas Natural features soft spots, a loose roll, and a draw that is a bit on the loose side. Maybe this one is best smoked in the dark.

Fortunately it gets better from here. A cold draw presents a “chocolatey tobacco” flavor and the wrapper scent is earthy with a little leather.

The Palmas Natural opens with a touch of harshness that abates after an inch or so and then becomes smooth and medium-bodied with a slightly citric tang. All three reviewers agree that the predominant flavor at this point is coffee; outlying flavors include cocoa, dark chocolate, and Lisa detected a hint of cloves.

Cigarfan and Lisa noted identical overtones in the middle section: cedar, leather, and a peppery taste that grows from this point onward. Despite the early indications of construction problems, there are no burn or draw issues aside from a slightly weak “zebra-colored” ash.

The flavors intensify into the last third, gathering leather and pepper together with a long earthy finish.

Maduro

The dark and oily wrapper on the maduro immediately gives it an edge over the natural. It’s still not a perfect beauty, but the rough and tough appearance of a maduro wrapper often seems to hide aesthetic flaws. In this case that is a very good thing, because again our reviewers hurled unflattering descriptors at the Palmas: “rough and wrinkled,” “large veins,” and “a little sloppy.” But Lucky7 remarked on the fine grain of the wrapper, and cigarfan found the dull oily sheen rather appealing.

Padron Palmas Maduro Wrapper

And where the natural version suffered from a loose roll, the maduro goes in the opposite direction. Our samples were firm to very tight; in one case the cigar was plugged. As always, we remind ourselves that cigars are handmade products and not every one is perfect. A plugged stick is certainly an anomaly for Padron, and this is the first one we’ve come across in recent memory.

Palmas Maduro - Sloppy Head ConstructionLisa noted a hint of “sun dried prunes” in her pre-light inspection. This is interesting in light of the prunes and raisins that Lucky7 and Brian found in the 7000 maduro.

The Palmas maduro starts up with a little harshness on the throat that gradually mellows after an inch or two. A woody flavor predominates, accented by notes of leather and a nutty sweetness, almost like hazelnut or coconut. Lucky7 described a “healthy nose twang” that slowly dissipates through the middle part of the cigar.

The middle section is creamier, smoother, and brings more flavors of coffee, leather and chocolate.

This long corona finishes up with “chewier flavors,” as Lisa says: roasted nuts, leather, vanilla, and pepper. Lucky7 found “toastier flavors” with a Palmas Maduro - Tilted Burn Linecocoa or java aftertaste, and cigarfan experienced burnt coffee and char in the last third.

Conclusion

While there was more agreement about the flavor characteristics of the natural Palmas than the maduro, all reviewers did agree on one thing: we preferred the maduro to the natural in this size. Both wrappers have their own distinctive tastes, as well as their own aesthetic flaws, but the maduro wins out for its earthy core and sweet molasses overtones.

Lisa added that this size in particular appeals to her:

“The Palmas vitola is quickly becoming my personal favorite to smoke. I feel like you get a nice concentration of flavors and an appreciation of learning to smoke slowly due its limited draw. Also, I feel women could feel really comfortable smoking this size and not feel like a fool. Long and slender really strikes an elegant profile.”

And there’s one thing nobody will argue about: the price. They’re straightforward smokes with a working class disposition, but they’re a great value and provide a smooth and even tempered smoking experience.

We certainly enjoyed working with Lisa on this review and wish her well with all things “Her Humidor”.

… cigarfan & lucky7

Padron Series 7000 (Comparison Review)

Padron Series 7000 Natural/Maduro

Skip the fluff and jump straight to the review!

Cigar Stats
Brand Owner: Padron Cigars, Inc. – Miami, FL (website)
(distributor operates under the name Piloto Cigars, Inc.)
Factory: Tabacos Cubanica, S.A. – Esteli, Nicaragua
Factory: Tabacos Centroamericanos, S.A. – Danli, Honduras
Model/Vitola: Padron Series 7000 (Natural and Maduro)
Size: 6.25 x 60 (toro)
Wrapper: Nicaragua
Filler & Binder: Nicaragua
Body: Medium to Full
Strength: Medium to Full
Average Retail: $6.31 USD
Cigar Insider/Aficionado Ratings: Consistently high 80s to low 90s

Fourteen other vitola sizes are available in the traditional Padron Series along with one which was recently discontinued.

Frontmark

Length x Ring

Shape

2000

5.0 x 50

robusto

3000

5.5 x 52

robusto

4000

6.5 x 54

toro

5000

5.5 x 56

robusto

6000

5.5 x 52

torpedo

7000

6.25 x 60

toro

Ambassador

6.875 x 42

lonsdale

Chicos

5.5 x 36

discontinued

Churchill

6.875 x 46

churchill

Corticos

4.25 x 35

short panatela

Delicias

4.875 x 46

corona extra

Executive

7.5 x 50

double corona

Londres

5.5 x 42

corona

Magnum

9.0 x 50

giant

Palmas

6.25 x 42

long corona

Panetela

6.875 x 36

panetela

All sizes come in laquered cedar boxes of 26, packaged with cellophane sleeves on individual cigars. Many vendors list a box size of 25. I am not entirely sure why that is. It may be that Padron changed the box count since the initial release. The Corticos are the exception packaged in boxes of 30 or tins of 6.

From the Padron website …..Jose Padron, Sr.

“We deliver only the finest, handmade, complex cigars with the flavor of the Cuban heritage out of which the Padron recipe was born. Our primary mission is the exceptional quality of our product, not the quantity produced. As a vertically integrated, family-owned company, we pay personal attention to every detail throughout all steps of our tobacco growing and cigar manufacturing process. Because we strive to give you, the smoker, the confidence that each cigar is the same ….. perfect.”

If you are interested in more KOTF info on the Padron Story, you can read it here.

The Keepers of the Flame Padron Series Roundup

Cigarfan & Lucky7

This comparison review is one in a series on the original Padron line of cigars. When we have completed reviews on the entire line, a vertical tasting for each wrapper will be published. Each review will be an amalgam opinion of cigarfan and lucky7 along with that of the guest reviewer(s). Our guest reviewers for this vitola are:

Brian - Stogie Review

Doc - Stogie Fresh

Padron Series 7000 – Natural and Maduro

The 60 ring gauge 7000 is the most recent addition to the classic Padron Series. It was released in the summer of 2007 at the RTDA in Houston, presumably in response to the trend toward large ring gauge cigars that started a few years back.

This is indeed a whopper of a smoke, and it can be expected to last for around 7000 with quarter for comparison90 minutes on average. Our reviewers noted that despite the size of the cigar it still feels balanced, and two of us attributed the generous volume and coolness of the smoke to the large bore of the barrel.

Maduro

The wrapper on the Maduro 7000 is rough with veins and a dull sheen of oil gives it a “matte” black appearance. The roll is a bit lumpy, but firm. The draw is very loose, perhaps excessively so. Lucky7 remedied this by punching the cap, but he found that halfway through the smoke he had to clip it with his Xikar to keep the smoke flowing smoothly. While not a deal-breaker, the loose draw may be responsible for some later burning and flavor issues.

The pre-light scent of the wrapper is classic barnyard or compost, and the cold taste is earthy. (Brian picked up some prunes in there, which is interesting because Lucky7 later tasted raisins. Cigarfan found some cereal grains in the natural version, so maybe if we put them all together we can call the 7000 a wholesome breakfast.)

An interesting sidenote about the wrapper on this cigar is the grain. The maduro wrapper on the 7000 is rough with small dots or bumps which are often called tooth, but in this case they aren’t. Grain is often confused with “tooth” because both are forms of stippling that occur in the texture of the wrapper. What we have here is grain that is caused by an overabundance of magnesium and potash in the soil from which the plant grew. For further explanation, allow us to refer you to Doc’s short treatise on the subject at Stogiefresh.com.

Doc's Review Stogies
Doc’s Review Stogies

The burn on the 7000 maddie is a bit bumpy at times, but for the most part it is self-correcting. The loose draw and large ring gauge may be partially responsible for it going out on two of the reviewers at the mid-way point; that aside, the burn was well behaved.

This maduro comes out of the gate with a playful bite that quickly mellows. Bean flavors are the predominating flavor here, though we didn’t all acknowledge the same bean: in the first third, reviewers reported variations of chocolate, cocoa, and coffee. The sugars in this wrapper add a level of sweetness that later in the stick become slightly carbonized and show up more char and toasty flavors.

Lucky7 nubbed the MaduroThe mid section of the cigar continues to provide plenty of rich sweet tobacco flavors, with notes of nuts and leather backing up the chocolate and coffee that continues from the first third. The body of this cigar is medium at this point, but it gradually approaches the full end of the spectrum. Lucky7 admired the way this stogie smoldered at this point with “blueish smoke from the foot mingling with the white smoke from the punched cap as together they waft up and out of sight.”

Leather takes over in the last third, with a strong sweet aroma reminiscent of the barbecue. Bean flavors are still prominent, but as the burn line approaches the nub these flavors darken and intensify. By the last inch and a half this cigar has given its all.

Natural

The general appearance of the Natural 7000 is similar to the maduro; in fact, the shade of the wrapper is only a few degrees lighter. Most of the adjectives used to describe the natural are not terribly flattering: lumpy, veiny, and mottled in color. Lumpy head on the NaturalBrian’s sample even featured a dime-sized patch near the head of the cigar. On the other hand, Doc gave this stick a little latitude when he described the wrapper as leathery, with a brushed velvet appearance, and cigarfan noted the grainy texture of the leaf.

In combination with the soft, almost mushy, roll of this stick, the 7000 natural is probably going to take a hit in the aesthetic department. But as Brian noted in reference to the simplicity of the band, this suggests that Padron is simply more concerned with quality than aesthetics.

The draw is a bit firmer than the maduro, but still quite free. As with the maduro, the burn wavers a little but is self-correcting. The ash is light gray, somewhat flaky, and shows small white dots of grain.

The natural opens with a initial burst of spice — one reviewer called it “raspy for the first half inch,” but then it backs off and mellows into cocoa, mocha coffee, and nuts. Cigarfan noted a grainy flavor as well, like cereal or raw fresh oats when you chew them up into a gum. There is a spicy tang on the tongue and some white pepper on the nose, but the overall texture of the smoke is still quite creamy.

The middle section of the cigar is smooth and pleasant. Descriptors here include buttery wood, earthy tobacco, toasted wood, and cocoa.

Into the last third, the body slowly builds and the nicotine powers up quite a bit. The spicy tang from early on morphs into pepper in the same regions of the palate while the cocoa turns to a light char. Other flavors make an exit at the nub and give way to lots of pepper and a bitter, dry aftertaste. And with that the last ash drops.

Full Size Padron Series 7000 (courtesy of Doc)Conclusion

The general consensus among our reviewers was that the Padron 7000 is a high quality, but not exemplary cigar. Some of us found the large ring gauge to be cumbersome at first, but the 7000 still smokes very well and burns more quickly than expected. That said, this is still a huge stick, and it requires a good hour and a half to do it justice.

Most reviewers preferred the maduro wrapper, which is in line with the general preference toward the maduro selections in this series. While published ratings show no overall performance difference, the ratings at Top25Cigar.com are higher for maduros than they are for the corresponding natural wrapper in almost every size.

Both the maduro and the natural Padron 7000 are fine smokes, but the maduro takes a slight edge. That little extra sweetness and helping of chocolate really made an impression on our panel, though most would prefer these flavors in a slightly smaller package.

Lastly, and for your viewing pleasure we include something no review including Brian’s handiwork should be without. We are happy to present, the first ever “twin” towers of burn. Our sincere thanks to Brian and Doc for assisting us with this first review in the Padron Series Roundup.

Padron Series 7000 Natural - Tower of BurnPadron Series 7000 Maduro - Tower of Burn

Aging Report: Medal of Honor “Intellect”

It’s been a little over two years since I visited the Medal of Honor Intellect, and while it hasn’t staged a remarkable transformation in that time, it’s still a really nice mellow smoke.

The Medal of Honor series was created for JR Cigars by Estelo Padron in Honduras to celebrate the cigar men who helped JR Cigars become the retail giant that it is today. This particular size honors Martin Herbst, who created the Maria Mancini and La Finca cigar brands.

I couldn’t remember exactly what went into this cigar when I pulled it out of long-term storage, and I decided to smoke it before refreshing my memory. This is not my habit at all, but since I’m quite familiar with this cigar I thought I could probably guess its composition.

My guess was wrong. Mid-way through this cigar I guessed that this was a Cameroon wrapper due to its bright cedary sweetness. I thought it was a little mild for Cameroon, but I attributed that to aging. For the first two inches it’s a simple blend of wood and cedar spice. As it turns out, this is actually an Ecuadorian Sumatra wrapper. The buttery texture (and lack of tooth in the wrapper) should have given it away, but not this time.

This has always been an easy going, mellow smoke, and it continues to be so. There isn’t much of a transition from first light to last ash, but this is nothing new either. The only surprise is a caramel spice in the second half that replaces the cedar from the first part. The foundation flavors remain woody from start to finish, and the aftertaste is pleasantly crisp and clean.

Construction values here have not changed over time and remain excellent — a beautiful solid ash and a razor sharp burn. Every one of these has been consistent in that regard.

The Medal of Honor Intellect is a mild mannered but articulate smoke that requires few words to make its point, which is well taken.

If you’re lucky enough to be sitting on a box of these from when they were first released in 2005, I’d say the time is ripe to break them out and pass them around to friends who enjoy lighter smokes; from this point forward I would expect them to simply make a gentle and gradual decline.

And if the mild-bodied stuff doesn’t interest you, stay tuned for the Padron Roundup scheduled to begin here on June 10 and continue for several weeks into the summer.

-cigarfan

Ancient Warrior Perfecto #2 by K. Hansotia

K. Hansotia and his Gurkha cigar line have done very well over the years by producing high quality cigars that are frequently veiled in mystique and hyperbole. Elaborate bands and boxes that border on the baroque are standard for Gurkha, not to mention the extreme “super premium” cigars infused with rare cognacs that have been advertised for $750 to over a thousand dollars per cigar. While producing some nice cigars, Mr. Hansotia evidently likes to put on a show as well.

But the fog that surrounds this line tends to obscure the simple facts, like who makes this cigar, and what is in the blend? The first Ancient Warriors I encountered were nothing like the ones I smoked for this review; in fact they weren’t even close to being the same — they were Brazilian puros with red bands and ribbons in a giant 7.5 x 50 size exclusive to Cigars International. (I was planning to review that cigar, but couldn’t get through more than half of it without wanting to shoot myself out of boredom. George at the Stogie Guys fared a little better.) So when I first saw the “regular” Ancient Warriors with the yellow and black labels in a local cigar shop, I was of course confused. That seems to be the nature of the Gurkha line.

In 2005, when the Ancient Warrior was introduced, a press release announced its composition:

  • Wrapper: Brazil
  • Binder: Costa Rica
  • Filler: Dominican Republic; Honduras

The information now available on their website (and confirmed by cigarcyclopedia.com) is that the binder is in fact Dominican. To muddy the water further, some retailer sites advertise a Nicaraguan binder. At some point the only thing you can do is throw up your hands and say, Who cares?

So, in that spirit, I clipped this attractive 5 x 56 zeppelin perfecto and put its foot to the fire.

My prelight impression of this cigar was mostly favorable: it smells like well aged and fermented maduro leaf. The roll is solid and even, and the wrapper is invitingly oily. It has a few prominent veins that give it a rustic appearance. The only real flaw here is that the wrapper bleeds a bit. Time to get out my Michael Jackson smoking glove.

Lighting this cigar was easy, and unlike some perfectos I’ve torched recently I didn’t have to play with the burn too much. The first flavor to make an entrance here is the theme to which this cigar returns over and over again: bittersweet chocolate. This is a really nice wrapper — in addition to the chocolate element, there’s a harmonious aroma that slowly turns from musk to wood.

It’s easy on the palate, starting with touches of sweetness on the tips and edges of the tongue and gradually developing a more earthy flavor. The smoke is smooth, medium-bodied, and easy going. The finish is moderate in length and the aftertaste is mildly bittersweet.

At the mid-way point the aroma becomes woodier, but it maintains its basically chocolate profile. Toward the end (for me a bit beyond the 2/3 point) it begins to heat up considerably, and it starts to lose its Bitter/Sweet balance. Finally it falters and falls away from chocolate into an overly tart bitterness.

Overall, the Ancient Warrior is a tasty smoke that offers a lot of flavor while remaining relatively tame. it’s similar to the Carlos Toraño Signature series, with a little less emphasis on the coffee flavors that the Signature offers.

The Ancient Warrior was reportedly designed to be a “more affordable” cigar, but when it comes to the Gurkha outfit it’s hard to tell if that’s the truth, or merely advertising. In any case, these are reasonably priced at around $100 for a box of 20 or $5 to $6 per stick.

The perfectos are a little hard to find right now, but our friends at Fumée World have the 60 ring gauge “El Duke” in stock right now for 5 bucks. And they’re offering a special deal for readers of Keepers of the Flame:

Enter the coupon code “keepersoftheflame” at checkout and get a FREE 1/2 pound bag of Black Dog Coffee!

A perfect companion to this cigar. Of course, the free coffee deal applies to any order from Fumée World, but for the first ten users only. Heather and Ralph run a great shop with the most personal and friendly customer service I’ve run across, so give them a call at 1-877-FUMEE-01 if you have any questions.

The Padron Series Roundup

Padron Series Band

Cigar Stats
Brand Owner: Padron Cigars, Inc. – Miami, FL (website)
(distributor operates under the name Piloto Cigars, Inc.)
Factory: Tabacos Cubanica, S.A. – Esteli, Nicaragua
Factory: Tabacos Centroamericanos, S.A. – Danli, Honduras
Line: Padron Series (the original line)
Wrapper: Natural and Maduro – Nicaragua
Filler & Binder: Nicaragua
Body: Medium to Medium Plus
Strength: Medium to Full
Cigar Insider/Aficionado Ratings: Consistently high 80s to low 90s

Fifteen sizes available in the Padron Series along with the Chicos which was recently discontinued.

Frontmark

Length x Ring

Shape

2000

5.0 x 50

robusto

3000

5.5 x 52

robusto

4000

6.5 x 54

toro

5000

5.5 x 56

robusto

6000

5.5 x 52

torpedo

7000

6.25 x 60

toro

Ambassador

6.875 x 42

lonsdale

Chicos

5.5 x 36

discontinued

Churchill

6.875 x 46

churchill

Corticos

4.25 x 35

short panatela

Delicias

4.875 x 46

corona extra

Executive

7.5 x 50

double corona

Londres

5.5 x 42

corona

Magnum

9.0 x 50

giant

Palmas

6.25 x 42

long corona

Panetela

6.875 x 36

panetela

All sizes come in laquered cedar boxes of 26, packaged with cellophane sleeves on individual cigars. Many vendors list a box size of 25. Not entirely sure why that is. It may be that Padron changed the box count since the initial release (or it may be select vendors have lost a cog “up there” somewhere). The Corticos are the exception packaged in boxes of 30 or tins of 6.

The Padron Series

As the Padron’s describe it … founded in 1964 and evolving throughout company history, the Padron Series today consists of sixteen medium-to full-bodied, long-filler cigars ranging from cigarillo to the large “A” size. All tobacco in this line is sun-grown habano aged a minimum of two-and-one-half years. Each vitola is available in a natural or maduro wrapper. The Padron Series offers exceptional quality and value.

Padron Series cigars are handmade, in one of two factories, with Cuban seed tobaccos grown entirely in Nicaragua. A true classic and unique-tasting cigar whose outstanding quality absolutely defies its affordable price. These perfectly balanced puros brim with flavor. Their consistency is family tradition which they are committed to maintaining it even if it means limiting production numbers.

The blend in each cigar is the same. The difference is in the size and shape which interestingly yield some distinctly different flavors. Just a note of caution. The Natural and Maduro versions of this line are quite difficult to tell apart visually. Be sure and mark them or store them separately otherwise you may just have to smoke ’em to tell which is which.

The Keepers of the Flame Padron RoundupJose Padron, Sr.

In the interest of providing a good roadmap to this extensive line of cigars, we are gearing up for what promises to be a challenging project. We have enlisted some of the best reviewers available in the cigar community and, in the coming months, will post a comparison review of the natural and maduro wrapper editions of each vitola in the list above based on a concensus of opinion. When that is done, we will publish a vertical tasting for each wrapper giving cigar shoppers a valuable resource for cigar selection decisions.

Although cigar reviews are very much subjective and based on personal opinion and palates, what better way to level the playing field than to have multiple experts weigh in. We have assembled a cadre of guest reviewers, from the blogroll here on Keepers of the Flame, to assist us in this mammoth project. For each vitola listed above, cigarfan, lucky7 and select guests will sample the smoke and offer their observations. A consolidation of those views will be presented in a consensus review here on Keepers of the Flame. In addition, we will link each review to the vitola listing above for central access.

An impressive list of reviewing talent by anyone’s standard.

Cigar Command
Ricky & Scott

Cigar Inspector
Inspector

Cigar Jack
Alex, Jeff & Jessie

Her Humidor
Lisa

Club Stogie
McCharlie & TXMatt

Matt's Cigar Journal
Matt

Stogie Review
Doc

Stogie Review
Brian & Walt

The Box Press
Kevin


GeorgeE, JonN & PatrickA

The Velvet Cigar
Ironmeden & Elvis

We are still gathering and distributing the raw materials for the project but look for the comparison reviews to begin in a few weeks. Until then … Disfrute de los Padrons!

Update — 5 June 2008: The fun has begun! As each vitola review is posted it is linked to the corresponding Frontmark in the table toward the top of this post.

Update — 29 July 2008: The comparison reviews are now complete. Look for our vertical tasting reports in a few weeks.

… cigarfan & lucky7

Augusto Reyes Criollo Corona

A few months back I gave the Augusto Reyes Nativo corona a walk around the block and found it to be a tasty — if a little bit quirky — cigar. Around the same time I pick up a couple of their cousins, the Augusto Reyes Criollo coronas. Having consigned my Nativos to the flames with fine results, I thought it was time for the Criollos to have their day of reckoning as well.

The robusto size in the AR Criollo line earned an accolade from the Robb Report as the “Best of the Best 2007.” I’m not sure how many cigars are entered into their evaluation, or what their technique is, but I would expect that they’re not testing too many Consuegras. Cruising in your Audi R8 with a Connie just ain’t happening.

The information I have on the blend is pretty basic: the binder and filler are Dominican, and the wrapper is Ecuadorian grown Connecticut Shade. One of the few articles I could find about this cigar is from a Dominican social news site, which relates that it was “designed for smokers who enjoy a blend a little smoother than the Nativo, but with a lot of aroma and flavor.” Having smoked this cigar, I have to disagree that it’s smoother, but it certainly does have plenty of flavor and a nice aroma.

I had forgotten that this cigar had a Connecticut wrapper when I first lit it up — because the name of the cigar is Criollo, I assumed that the wrapper was as well. So I was surprised by the first few puffs, which were smooth and nutty. Hmmm, I thought. It’s almost like Connecticut Shade. After half an inch or so I changed my mind because a touch of cayenne kicks in; too spicy to be Connecticut, I thought.

My first impression was correct, of course. The Connecticut wrapper itself is a smooth claro in shade, with a very light sheen of oil and miniscule veins. The draw is excellent, and these little coronas burn perfectly to a solid light gray ash.

Into the second third the Criollo turns up the intensity. The flavor turns from nuts with a bit of pepper to earth with even more pepper, and the finish lengthens considerably. The aroma contrasts with the changes in the flavor of the cigar in an interesting way — as the flavor takes on more minerals and becomes richer, the aroma seems sweeter.

The last third is positively punchy. This is basically a medium-bodied cigar, but the nicotine content is nothing to sneeze at. The flavor is intensely earthy, almost ashy at times, and the aftertaste is overpowering. Some might call this “harsh,” but I find it just very intense. On the other hand, if earthy is not your thing, you’ll want to avoid this smoke.

The “criollo” in this smoke is obviously not from the wrapper — it’s from the blend itself, which has a lot in common with the flavors of Creole food — charbroiled seafood, paprika, and cayenne. Topped off with a little sweet nuttiness from that wrapper and a good dose of nicotine.

The Augusto Reyes Criollo line runs a little less than the Nativo, but not by much. Expect to see these for around 7 USD, if at all. They’re still in production, but not exactly ubiquitous. Consuegras they’re not. Just ask the folks at the Robb Report.

–cigarfan